Comparison of Absorptive ND Filter and Reflective ND Filter
|
Feature
|
Reflective ND Filter
|
Absorptive ND Filter
|
Attenuation Mechanism
|
Reflective
|
Absorptive
|
Thermal Effect
|
Low (no heat from reflected light)
|
High (absorption of light into heat)
|
Damage Threshold
|
Higher (for high power lasers)
|
Lower (may be damaged by overheating)
|
Spectral Neutrality
|
Excellent (dependent on coating process)
|
Good (adulterated materials may have slight color deviation)
|
Angular Sensitivity
|
Higher (large angle of incidence may change OD value)
|
Lower
|
Cost
|
Higher
|
Lower
|
What are the considerations for choosing a reflective neutral density filter?
Power Tolerance:
Confirmation of laser wavelength and power density (e.g. CO₂ lasers require ZnSe substrates).
Dielectric ND filters typically withstand >1 kW/cm² (pulsed lasers require additional consideration of peak power).
Stray Light Treatment:
Reflected light needs to be directed in a harmless direction (e.g. beam traps).
Spectral Range:
Ultraviolet (UV) or infrared (IR) bands require special coatings (e.g. UV fused silica substrate).